There’s file-sharing and there’s file-sharing
Kinda like Cannabis, says German official
SWAMPED UNDER THOUSANDS of file-sharing violation investigations, the General Prosecutor’s Office of the German state of North-Rhine Westphalia has set the bar to separate commercial file-sharing and misdemeanor file-sharing.
According to an interview on Jetzt.de, Axel Steel (real name), spokesman for said office says the rule of thumb for prosecution to deem someone as a " commercial file-sharer" is: songs are worth a €urobuck, movies are worth €15. If you don’t share over €3,000 of material then you won’t be prosecuted.
You are still violating the law if you share; it’s just that the Prosecutor’s office is too under-manned to follow-up on the 25,000 violations that have been reported in the first half of 2008 alone.
The official carries on to compare file-sharing with cannabis consumption – "both very popular among youths" he says – it is illegal to consume it, but people do it anyway, and the authorities can’t be bothered in frying smaller fish as it’s a waste of time and resources. Going after the big distributors is the way to go.
We reckon there is an evveeerrr so slight difference between cannabis and file-sharing. With file-sharing you get to share a single file multiple times (and it never loses its buzz), so does the official they mean the value of a single song/movie or the value of the number of times it’s been shared with others? We’re waiting on an answer, on that one…
So according to Mr. Steel, as long as you share under the €3,000 bar, the advanced legal radar of the state prosecutors office won’t pick you up. You’re still committing a crime, though, but it isn’t big enough for the State to pursue. There are situations where they will prosecute under this level of sharing, however, but those warrant more direct inspection.
We can hear the brouhaha from the record companies right now… Smoke ‘em if you got ‘em. This is going to be a fun trip. µ

Comments
Actually Makes Sense
This makes sense, and is refreshing to hear.It seems a good place to start, although the cannabis analogy is a bound to be too controversial for some. But we need more people to take a stance like this, as the war is currently being lost through rhetoric, and actually using financials to justify not criminalising the small-fry might just work.
More and more this is all a matter of public perspective, and more intelligent arguments like this could just swing it the way of common sense.
Proof
I still think that the MAAFIA should provide definitive proof of file sharing going on, and not the shared folder BS they have been trying to pass as legitimate piracy.Cannabis?
Will cannabis ever stop getting a bad name?I am quite disgusted that it's trade is seen to be as bad as illegal file sharing.
MAFIAA, make a monthly deal of £x/$x per month
and allow downloaders to download as much as they want to.You, the MAFIAA, could be sitting on a goldmine easily 10x the size of Apple's Itunes right now.
Keep it simple - if you take the downloader contract with your ISP then you're legally downloading anything. Allow any p2p type program, it doesn't matter about that because it's the content you're interested in.
How to work out who gets the moolah? Simple, a download chart of the top X amount of files (movies, songs, software, anything). The more popular something is the bigger the slice of the pie they get.
You could also give a small amount to the most popular p2p applications, and make other awards for adding features like ease of use and security. Afterall you want the whole world on this monthly donation to your pockets, so make it easy for everyone, kids, adults, oldies.
The internet is the greatest and cheapest delivery method ever created, I just cannot get over just how stupid on a global level you guys have been for over a decade. It's just incredible. It's staring you in the face, just how easy this is to do, but you're not going for it. Please go for it.
Summary: FIle sharing is legal if you pay £5/$10/€7 a month. All the payments systems are already in place, users just get the addon from their ISP, and that gets passed on to you minus admin. Money for nothing.
Steel?!
This may be pedantic, but when did we start to translate names? The guy's name is Axel Stahl. So long, Paul Schneider.This is about SAP & Oracle, Roight?
Well now if I were the president of this landYou know I'd declare total war on the pusher man.
I'd cut him if he stands, and I'd shoot him if he run,
And I'd kill him with my bible, and my razor and my gun....
Whoops! must have been a momentary lap of Freudian pils.